Recently I was creating a “States of Matter” kindergarten, first grade and 2nd grade science craft that needed fake ice as a collage item. The craft shows solid, liquid, and gas in collage form, and since ice is my solid, I decided to test which material would work best.

My requirements were:
- easy for young hands to use (5 – 7 year-olds)
- easy to obtain (household items are even better)
- easy to set up in a classroom
- most importantly, it needs to look like ice
How I Tested the Materials
I printed two pages of the ice cube template included in my “States of Matter Collage Craft” pack and painted one set of ice cubes light blue and left the other plain. When I do this in class, I’ll print the ice cubes on light blue paper instead. I then glued the various items onto each ice cube template.
(TEACHING TIP: Remind students to glue the paper, not the collage item.)
Collage Materials I Tested
The blue-painted ice cubes:
- silver glitter
- crumpled plastic food wrap
- small pieces of bubble wrap
- crumpled plastic bag
- coarse salt
- fine salt
- blue dot painting (done with a bingo dabber)
The plain ice cubes:
- silver glitter
- crumpled plastic food wrap
- small pieces of bubble wrap
- crumpled plastic bag
- coarse salt
- fine salt
- white tissue paper (the kind clothing is wrapped in when you buy it – yes, I hoard this stuff!)
- blue tissue paper
- blue paper napkin
NOTE: I didn’t glue the tissue or napkin onto the blue-painted cubes, since they would cover the paint anyway.

My top pick is coarse salt on the blue background, which looked better than the plain paper with every material. It meets all my requirements, and as a bonus, it’s environmentally friendly (no plastic always a goal for me). Coarse salt is inexpensive, and for this craft each student would only need around a teaspoon. I love how it sparkles like ice crystals, and it’s super easy for little hands to sprinkle onto the glued paper.
TEACHING TIP: Once the salt is sprinkled on, have students press down gently with their palm so it sticks.
Want the ice cube template and the rest of the solid, liquid, and gas collage craft? Take a peek at my States of Matter Collage Craft on Teachers Pay Teachers. This craft is part of my “Science Crafts Growing Bundle for kindergarten, First Grade and Second Grade”, I have lots of science craft ideas to add soon.

Leave a Reply